Welcome to Silver Innings Blog, Good Day

Powered by IP2Location.com

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

The Rationale for Pension Parity in India

Pension is a deferred wage, paid in consideration of past service which an employee rendered sacrificing the prime of his youth for the sake of the Government & the quantum of such pension should be such that he is able to lead a dignified Life in his twilight years maintaining as far as possible the standard of living he was used to during his service life!

It is in view of this basic principle that the apex court of the country has repeatedly ruled that any classification of pensioners at any time will have to answer the test of article 14 of the Constitution and further concluded that pensioners for the purpose of pensionary benefits form a homogeneous class and such a homogeneous class could not be arbitrarily divided on the basis of dates of retirement whenever the pension undergoes an upward revision and hence the fixation, at any time, of any cut off date for any new benefit is arbitrary.

Any act which seeks to classify or divide pensioners into two or more classes is not based on any rational principle, and hence it would constitute a violation of article 14 of the Constitution. Thus, parity of pension as between one who retires with a certain pay and a certain rank on a particular date and another one who draws the same pay and with the same rank but retires on a subsequent date is thus a constitutional right guaranteed under article 14 of the Constitution and sanctified by the apex court and many High Courts in their landmark judgments.

The demand for one-rank-one pension for all Defence personnel or pension equal to 50%of the pay as notionally revised in the new pay structure corresponding to the scales from which the employee retired is therefore a just one, which the government should readily accept .The argument of huge financial burden on the national exchequer and the danger of the economy being thrown out of gear to reject this just demand is just a bogey and indeed this has never been accepted by the apex court and many High Courts.

If the arbitrary and frequent increase in the remuneration of Members of legislatures without any public discussion and generally by voice vote, and of Ministers & top bureaucrats (read IAS) or those in the higher echelons of administration, the huge expenditure on the security of politicians, which is generally more of a status symbol than any genuine security cover, the circulation of fake Currency, the absence of any effort to rein in the parallel grey market economy, the gobbling of resources earmarked for social welfare schemes by politicians and vested intermediaries etc. are not going to involve a huge drain on the national exchequer and thereby derail the Indian economy, then how can the just demand of those who actually spared no effort and bore on their shoulders during the prime period of their lives the brunt of running the administration to meet the loud articulations of the rising hopes and aspirations of the common man in the newly emerging independent India, can be thrown out on the ground that it would cause a serious financial imbalance and throw the Indian economy out of gear? Why is only the poor pensioner being made to suffer for no fault of his? He is suffering perhaps because he has so far not realized his own power i.e. the power of vote.

It need hardly be pointed out that generally one retired person has in his hands the power of 6 votes i.e of himself, his spouse, his son, his daughter-in-law, his grand daughter & grand son. There are almost two crores of such pensioners (i.e from the Centre, the States, the Defence establishments, the Railways, the PSUs, Banks, the Education department etc.) and they would thus constitute a vote bank of about 12 crores. So the clarion call to all the pensioners is: “Stop crying, wake up and realize the enormous power in your hands. The Governments & the politicians seem to understand only the language and power of the Vote Bank. You cannot fight your battle individually, nor do you generally have the wherewithal to do so.

So, join the larger community of senior citizens and consolidate your own Vote Bank. Once you do so, the politicians will come running to you & you will get what you want. Let not any further time be lost in consolidating the vote bank. So, hasten, lend your helping hand and strengthen the hands of the organizations that have dedicated themselves to improving the lot and welfare of the pensioners”.

By S.C.Maheshwari
Email: pensioner77@yahoo.com


http://www.indiamydreamland.blogspot.com/ said...

Dear Mr Maheshwari,
You have given a very fine and logical summing up of the rationale for the parity in pensions. But will our Government act in a similar logical and humane manner and stand by the various judgements of the Apex Court to undo the sufferings of lakhs and lakhs of pensioners in India? They, will prefer to keep challenging these decisions on flimsy and illogical grounds to torture the Senior Citizens. For exercising the power of vote we will have to wait for another five years and by then many would have left this world to lighten the burden of this ungrateful Government of India.

I am also posting your write up on my Blog "India of My Dreams" at http://www.indiamydreamland.blogspot.com/

Col LK Anand

Subrahmanian S H said...

Well Said, Col Anand.
Even 'one one pension' is pending for long
I don't remember in which of my blogs I dwelt on the subject. Let me try to fing the gist in my System.
Is there any group, Dr Maheshwari, for us?

SCM said...

Dear col.Anand
You must have fought battles leading your men from front line, defending the country w/o caring for your life . This is just another battle for the Rights & Welfare of Sr citizen, then why care whether we live to reap the Fruits or not. Some one will have to start some day from some where, then why not we start right now to give definite line of action to the coming Generations of oldies. A veteran need not be reminded that Rome was not built in a day.
Kindly have a look at ppt Elderly Vote power :

SCM said...

Dear sh. SHS,
Isugest, please go through PPT
Elderly Vote Power :
Also pl. participate in the Pension related discussions on www.rrewa.org & on gconnect
If we interlink Sr citizens & pensioners websites,Blogs & publications.We can have our own Media platform .
For grievance redressal you can use online grievance registration links available uner the button "Gievance redressal" on www.rrewa.org Home page.

Blogsite Disclaimer

The content of this Blog, including text, graphics, images, information are intended for General Informational purposes only. Silver Innings Blog is not responsible for, and expressly disclaims all liability for, damages of any kind arising out of use, reference to, or reliance on any information contained within the site. While the information contained within the site is periodically updated, no guarantee is given that the information provided in this Web site is correct, complete, and up-to-date.The links provided on this Blog do not imply any official endorsement of, or responsibility for, the opinions, data, or products available at these locations. It is also the user’s responsibility to take precautionary steps to ensure that information accessed at or downloaded from this or linked sites is free of viruses, worms, or other potentially destructive software programs.All links from this Blog are provided for information and convenience only. We cannot accept responsibility for sites linked to, or the information found there. A link does not imply an endorsement of a site; likewise, not linking to a particular site does not imply lack of endorsement.We do not accept responsibility for any loss, damage or expense resulting from the use of this information.Opinions expressed by contributors through discussion on the various issues are not necessarily those of Silver Innings Blog.